Comparison
Four ways to produce a bill.
Every costs team in England and Wales is choosing between the same four options. This is the comparison we would want to read before spending £950: what each one costs, what it protects, and where it quietly fails.
Good to know
- We are the fourth column. Judge the first three on their own terms, then decide whether paying for the fourth is worth it.
- Options
- Manual · Agency · Template · Costs Engine
- Credit cost
- £25 PAYG · ~£13–£21 on annual packs
- Data
- Stays local
Side by side
The same eight questions, four answers.
Turnaround and marginal cost are the obvious rows. The ones that decide whether a bill survives assessment are further down.
Time to a first draft
- By hand
- Two or three evenings per bill
- Agency
- Days to weeks, in their queue
- Template
- A day, if the ledger is already clean
- Costs Engine
- Minutes of assembly, then your review
Cost of an extra file
- By hand
- Another evening you cannot bill
- Agency
- 6–8% of profit costs, or hourly
- Template
- Your time, every single time
- Costs Engine
- 2–6 credits (~£26–£127 on packs, or £50–£150 PAYG)
Rate capping
- By hand
- Manual, entry by entry
- Agency
- Whatever their drafter does
- Template
- Whatever the template was built with
- Costs Engine
- Every entry, against the table in force on its date
Scanned vouchers
- By hand
- Retyped by hand
- Agency
- Sent to them to type
- Template
- Not read at all
- Costs Engine
- Parsed locally for payee, net and VAT
Entries J-coded by hand
- By hand
- Every one, from a dropdown
- Agency
- Typed again by their drafter
- Template
- Entered into the template
- Costs Engine
- Read from the ledger, phased on the spot
Audit before filing
- By hand
- If there is time left
- Agency
- Their own checklist
- Template
- None
- Costs Engine
- Block-billing, duplicate narratives, unvouched fees, A9
Missed recoverables
- By hand
- Found by luck, after service
- Agency
- Whatever their check turns up
- Template
- Not looked for
- Costs Engine
- Vouchers matched to the schedule; omissions flagged in pink
The workbook itself
- By hand
- Rebuilt or patched by hand
- Agency
- Their file, their format
- Template
- Formulas and pivots break as it fills
- Costs Engine
- Written into the official MoJ template, pivots intact
Where the matter goes
- By hand
- Stays with you
- Agency
- Leaves your firm
- Template
- Stays with you
- Costs Engine
- Stays on your machine
Multi-year matters
- By hand
- One workbook per year, merged by hand
- Agency
- Their file, their format
- Template
- Rebuilt when the rates change
- Costs Engine
- One workbook, every year of the matter
Who signs the bill
- By hand
- You
- Agency
- You
- Template
- You
- Costs Engine
- You
| Question | By handIn-house drafter | AgencyOutsourced | TemplateSpreadsheet | Costs EngineDesktop engine |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Time to a first draft | Two or three evenings per bill | Days to weeks, in their queue | A day, if the ledger is already clean | Minutes of assembly, then your review |
| Cost of an extra file | Another evening you cannot bill | 6–8% of profit costs, or hourly | Your time, every single time | 2–6 credits (~£26–£127 on packs, or £50–£150 PAYG) |
| Rate capping | Manual, entry by entry | Whatever their drafter does | Whatever the template was built with | Every entry, against the table in force on its date |
| Scanned vouchers | Retyped by hand | Sent to them to type | Not read at all | Parsed locally for payee, net and VAT |
| Entries J-coded by hand | Every one, from a dropdown | Typed again by their drafter | Entered into the template | Read from the ledger, phased on the spot |
| Audit before filing | If there is time left | Their own checklist | None | Block-billing, duplicate narratives, unvouched fees, A9 |
| Missed recoverables | Found by luck, after service | Whatever their check turns up | Not looked for | Vouchers matched to the schedule; omissions flagged in pink |
| The workbook itself | Rebuilt or patched by hand | Their file, their format | Formulas and pivots break as it fills | Written into the official MoJ template, pivots intact |
| Where the matter goes | Stays with you | Leaves your firm | Stays with you | Stays on your machine |
| Multi-year matters | One workbook per year, merged by hand | Their file, their format | Rebuilt when the rates change | One workbook, every year of the matter |
| Who signs the bill | You | You | You | You |
The case against
When Costs Engine is the wrong answer.
Three situations where we would tell you to keep your money.
You only produce one or two short N260s a year
Skip the annual plan — use £25 Pay-As-You-Go credits (£50 per Form N260) only when an urgent hearing lands, or draft short schedules by hand.
You want someone else to write the narratives
Costs Engine assembles and flags; it does not argue the bill for you. If what you actually want is the drafting judgment itself, that is an agency's job rather than software's.
Your disbursement data is already clean
If your case management system hands you a well-formed ledger and vouchers that need no reading, the heaviest part of the work is already done.
The pattern is the same in all three: Costs Engine pays for itself on volume and on mess. If you have neither, an evaluation will tell you so in a week.
The trade
What you are actually buying.
Not a promise about outcomes. A change in where the hours go.
Three days → twenty minutes
The backlog becomes a review. The drafting judgment is untouched.
~£13–£21 per credit on packs
N260 uses 2 credits, Precedent H 3 credits and Precedent S 6 credits — or £25/credit on Pay-As-You-Go.
One licence, every desktop
A seat is a named drafter, so the same person can work from any machine they use.
Decide on evidence
Run the comparison on your own matter.
Fourteen days, one live file, both methods if you like. We will not ask for a case study in return.
Comparison
Cheaper per bill, or cheaper to do nothing?
Draft one matter by hand and one in Costs Engine. The second bill will tell you more than this page can.
One reply, one call, one decision. We will not add you to a sequence.
